The Role of Behavioural Biases in Shaping Individual Saving Patterns: Evidence From India
📄
Abstract
Abstract:
🏷️
Keywords
📖
Full Article
I. Introduction
Saving is defined as the allocation of a part of a person’s earnings
for upcoming usage instead of current consumption, and this remains a very
important decision in personal financial management. Traditional economic
theories assume that individuals act rationally in their choice of how much to
save, taking into account their future income throughout their lives [1].
Nevertheless, in contrast to traditional theories, multiple studies over the
years testify to continued under-saving from all over the world [2].
Behavioural economics that originated from the works of Kahneman and
Tversky, then developed further with the contribution of Thaler and Laibson and
many others, is said to provide a more realistic method of financial
decision-making. The present paper analyses five biases connected to saving:
1) present
bias, which means the propensity to give much more importance to immediate
smaller gains than to much bigger gains occurring in the future [3];
2) loss
aversion, which entails the fact that losses are felt in approximately twice as
strong a way as equivalent gains [4];
3) mental
accounting, which means that individuals treat money differently depending on
its origin [5];
4) overconfidence
which is associated with inflated opinions about one’s competence in finance
and can lead to under-provisioning for emergencies; and;
5) self-control
problems, which cause saving intentions to collapse in the face of immediate
spending temptations [6].
India presents a unique context to explore these issues. The country
traditionally has a high level of household savings; however, the composition
of savings has moved from physical to financial assets and the total amount of
savings has undergone a downward trend. The situation is defined by low levels
of financial literacy, a broad informal labour market, and an increasing number
of financial products accessible by a growing middle class. For the time being,
the bulk of Indian studies on savings has centered around macroeconomic factors
influencing saving (like such factors as income, inflation, interest rates)
with psychological factors being studied less.
This paper fills in that gap. The main problem of research refers to
the issue of under-saving for people from different income classes in India,
even for those who can be seen as middle- or high-income people because such
groups have enough capacity for savings. Accordingly, this research asks: which
behavioural biases are most prevalent among individuals, and to what extent do
they shape saving frequency, the proportion of income saved, emergency-fund
maintenance, and the choice of savings instrument, and does this influence vary
across demographic groups such as age, gender, income, and occupation?
The research offers three significant contributions. Firstly, it
looks at five types of human behavioural biases as a joint phenomenon instead
of a separate one, which provides a solution to the problem of many studies
discussing only one type of bias. Secondly, it uses original data obtained in
India to study biases. Finally, it connects the level of bias with observable
effects in savings behaviour and derives practical recommendations for
regulators, banks, and educational institutions from the results of the
research.
II. Literature Review and Conceptual Framework
The classical starting point for research on saving is the rational,
forward-looking consumer of the Life-Cycle and Permanent Income Hypotheses [1],
[7], [8], in which saving decisions today are optimised against expected income
over an individual's full lifetime. These models remain the normative benchmark
against which behavioural deviations are measured, but they were built on
assumptions of unlimited self-control and unbiased expectations that a large
body of subsequent research has challenged.
Behavioral economics provides the concept behind different
behaviours’ acceptance. According to Prospect Theory [4] people make judgments
about gains and losses based on a reference point, giving different weights to
losses than to gains, which explains the trend of people to choose savings
products being perceived as ‘safe’ despite their low profitability. The concept
developed by Thaler [5], known as mental accounting, indicates that people do
not treat money as a homogeneous good, creating budgets in their minds based on
various sources of income and using different rules for managing budgets.
Laibson [3] developed the concept of hyperbolic discounting or present bias,
which means that people cannot save money in the present moment, even if they
plan to do so in the future. The theory from Shefrin and Thaler [6] called the
Behavioral Life-Cycle Hypothesis summarizes all of the abovementioned concepts
under one theory, pointing out that the conflict occurs within the same person
between the plan-making part of the personality and the part that does not
remain attentive to future prospects.
A smaller body of empirical literature has connected these variables
directly to savings outcomes, typically in settings with a bias towards either
a Western or East Asian perspective. For instance, the effect of commitment
mechanisms on savings behaviour in the Philippines [9], the earmarking effect
on savings for poor demographics [10], the significance of financial literacy
in retirement planning [11], the SMarT program implementing automatic
escalation in the USA to bring about increased retirement savings [12], and
macro evidence of increased savings for urban Chinese households [13]. The
Reserve Bank of India offers data regarding the macroeconomic situation behind
Indian saving, but its data provides little comprehension regarding the
psychological significance of it.
The existing literature exhibits five critical voids providing the
impetus for this research: an inordinate focus on investment instead of savings
behavior; an almost exclusive focus on biases existing in isolation instead of
utilizing framework of multiple biases; an existence of Western viewpoint
within the evidence with underrepresentation of India; excessive tendency for
measuring bias strength while failing to connect it with observable saving
behavior; and limited utilization of observable evidence for suggesting
policies in the context of developing economies. Building upon the framework of
Behavioural Life-Cycle Hypothesis and utilization of Prospect Theory,
hyperbolic discounting, and mental accounting in concept of biases, the present
research proposes that savings behavior is affected by the strength of the
biases and that this effect is moderated through demographic characteristics of
respondents including age, sex, income, and occupation.
III. Methodology
A. Research
Design and Sample
The approach adopted by this research is cross-sectional and
involves a quantitative descriptive investigation. To acquire primary data, an
original questionnaire was constructed and deployed through Google Forms and
distributed using purposive and convenience sampling, collecting data through
online platforms like WhatsApp, identifying three categories of respondents:
students, working people, and the general public. The sample collected consists
of 177 completed responses sourced primarily from respondents located in
Gujarat while also including responses from Mumbai, Pune, Bengaluru, Hyderabad,
Delhi, Jaipur, and a few other places, thus meeting the geographical spread
requirement while remaining in the same state. The research is exploratory and
descriptive in nature and thus, the researcher reduced the need for primary
data collection and employed non-probability sampling as the primary sampling
method, despite its implications on generalisability as discussed in Section
VI.
B. Instrument and
Measures
The questionnaire that consists of 33 items is divided into eight
sections. Section A contains demographic data (age, sex, occupation, education,
earnings, and city of residence). Section B contains measurements of four
aspects of the saving behavior: frequency of saving (an ordinal scale from
"Never" to "Very Often"), percentage of monthly income
saved, availability of emergency funds, savings instruments used, and
comparison of actual savings and expected savings at the beginning of the year.
There are four items from Sections C–G each with a Likert-type scale (1 =
Strongly Disagree to 5 = Strongly Agree) aimed at doing an analysis of one of
five biases targeted: present bias, loss aversion, mental accounting,
overconfidence, and lack of self-control. Section H has two optional open-ended
questions about the main barrier to saving without interruption and an
accidental financial decision.
C. Analytical
Approach
The use of descriptive statistics allowed us to analyze the profiles
of participants in terms of their demographics and saving behavior.Cronbach's
alpha was used to find out whether the four-item bias scales displayed a
satisfactory level of reliability in each case (minimum level of acceptance α ≥
.70). Pearson's correlation coefficients served to determine the
interdependence of composite scores for individual biases and saving frequency
(α = .05). A simple linear regression analysis was performed to assess the
predictive capability of a single bias significantly correlated with the
dependent variable. The average bias scores were also checked for consistency
in terms of occupational status, age, and gender differences, while qualitative
data obtained from open-ended questions were analyzed in search of common
themes that would confirm or supplement findings obtained through quantitative
study. The study was conducted in line with human research ethical
requirements, which means that participation was free of charge, no personally
identifiable information other than the participants' places of residence was
collected, and collected data were used only for research purposes.
IV. Results
A. Sample Profile
and Saving Behaviour
According to the research, the 177 respondents surveyed revealed
that 35 percent were aged between 20 and 25 years old, while 32.2 percent were
aged 45 or older. The rest of the respondents included individuals across the
other age brackets. Additionally, the gender makeup of survey participants was
almost evenly divided. Approximately 52 percent of respondents were female and
48 percent male. Students comprised the majority of job categories at 39.5
percent, being followed by status salaried private sector individuals and
business owners at 21.5 percent and 20.3 percent, respectively. Furthermore,
42.9 percent of the respondents admitted to earning less than ₹10,000 monthly,
which indicates the dominance of students among the surveyed population.
TABLE
I
Demographic
profile of respondents (N = 177).
|
Variable |
Category |
n |
% |
|
Age |
20–25 years |
62 |
35.0 |
|
|
Above 45 years |
57 |
32.2 |
|
|
26–35 years |
25 |
14.1 |
|
|
36–45 years |
20 |
11.3 |
|
|
Below 20 years |
13 |
7.3 |
|
Gender |
Female |
92 |
52.0 |
|
|
Male |
85 |
48.0 |
|
Occupation |
Student |
70 |
39.5 |
|
|
Salaried
(Private) |
38 |
21.5 |
|
|
Self-employed/Business |
36 |
20.3 |
|
|
Salaried
(Govt./PSU) |
11 |
6.2 |
|
|
Homemaker |
10 |
5.6 |
|
Monthly income |
Below ₹10,000 |
76 |
42.9 |
|
|
Above ₹1,00,000 |
30 |
16.9 |
The saving behavior revealed a significant intention-action gap.
53.1% of those surveyed said they save regularly or very often, while 46.9%
save only occasionally or very rarely. Moreover, 36.2% of respondents save at
least 5-10% of their income, while 24.9% save either less than 5% or nothing.
One interesting fact is that 48.0% of those surveyed saved less than their
original intention at the beginning of the year, while only 15.3% of
respondents saved more than they planned to. In addition to that, emergency
fund accumulation is also not found satisfactory: 45.7% never think about
saving for emergency reasons or have no savings at all; only 31.1% of
respondents managed to save at least three months of their expenses.
B. Reliability
and Composite Bias Scores
Cronbach's alpha values showed that Present Bias had good internal
consistency (α = .803), while Loss Aversion (α = .666) and Self-Control
Problems (α = .643) were reasonably consistent. Although Mental Accounting was
moderately reliable, with α = .447, the result likely demonstrates that this
construct is multidimensional. In contrast, the Cronbach's alpha value for
Overconfidence is low (α = .059), meaning that its items do not measure a
single property of Overconfidence.
All five biases have mean scores greater than the midpoint of the
scale, proving that they were present in the study sample. Mental Accounting
had the highest mean score of 3.18, and the second highest was Self-Control
Problems with mean score of 3.16. Overconfidence had a mean score of 3.10, Loss
Aversion scored 2.96, and Present Bias had the lowest mean score of 2.54, but
had a statistically significant relationship with saving frequency.
TABLE
II
Mean
composite bias scores and scale reliability (scale 1–5, N = 177).
|
Bias |
M |
α |
Rank |
|
Mental
Accounting |
3.18 |
.447 |
1 |
|
Self-Control
Problems |
3.16 |
.643 |
2 |
|
Overconfidence
Bias |
3.10 |
.059 |
3 |
|
Loss Aversion |
2.96 |
.666 |
4 |
|
Present Bias |
2.54 |
.803 |
5 |
C. Present Bias
as a Predictor of Saving Frequency
The Pearson correlations computed for all biases versus saving
frequency revealed that only Present Bias had a significant relationship (r =
-0.548, p < .001), while Loss Aversion (r = -0.065, p = .461), Mental
Accounting (r = -0.094, p = .288), Overconfidence (r = -0.116, p = .189), and
Self-Control Problems (r = -0.045, p = .612) were not significantly correlated
with saving frequency at 5%. The simple linear regression of saving frequency
on Present Bias was significant, F(1, 175) = 67.43, p < .001; Present Bias
explained approximately 30% of the variance in saving frequency (R² = 0.300,
adjusted R² = 0.296). The unstandardized coefficient (B = -0.812, SE = 0.099, β
= -0.548) showed that a one-point increase in Present Bias was related to a
decrease in saving frequency by 0.812 points on a five-point scale in line with
the theoretical predictions of hyperbolic discounting [3].
TABLE
III
Simple
linear regression: Present Bias predicting saving frequency.
|
Parameter |
Value |
|
R² |
0.300 |
|
Adjusted R² |
0.296 |
|
F(1, 175) |
67.43, p < .001 |
|
Constant
(Intercept) |
4.60 (SE = 0.268) |
|
Present Bias
coefficient (B) |
-0.812 (SE = 0.099) |
|
Standardised β |
-0.548 |
D. Demographic
Patterns
Among all occupational categories, students reported the highest
mean scores on Present Bias (M = 2.82), Mental Accounting (M = 3.47), and
Self-Control Problems (M = 3.40), depicting their relatively limited knowledge
about long-term planning and irregular remuneration; conversely, government and
PSU employees reported the lowest mean on Present Bias (M = 2.23), which can be
attributed to the roles of salary-based compulsory methods of savings. By age,
scores for Present Bias reached the maximum value (M = 2.94) for the segment of
20 to 25-year-olds, while the greatest mean scores for both Loss Aversion and
Self-Control Problems occurred within the 36 to 45 segment, reaching M = 3.45;
such age pattern can be explained by involvement of people in high-stake
financial situations such as taking out mortgages or performing saving for
retirement or children's education. The analysis of gender differences showed
that men scored a bit higher on Present Bias (M = 2.59 vs. 2.50), while women
achieved a slightly greater score on Loss Aversion (M = 3.07 vs. 2.85).
E. Savings
Instruments and Qualitative Themes
Bank savings accounts and fixed deposits were the most widely used
instrument (68% of respondents), followed by mutual funds/SIPs (41%,
concentrated among 20–35 year-olds), gold and physical assets (35%,
concentrated among older respondents and homemakers), insurance-linked products
(29%), post-office/PPF instruments (22%), informal saving including cash and
chit funds (18%), and direct equity (15%). Open-ended responses converged with
the quantitative findings: the most commonly cited barrier to consistent saving
was small, unplanned day-to-day spending, and many respondents deferred saving
with statements such as intending to start 'next month' or 'once expenses
stabilise' — a qualitative echo of present bias. The most commonly cited
financial regret was impulsive discretionary spending, particularly around
online sales, corroborating the self-control and present-bias findings from the
quantitative analysis and confirming that the gap observed is one of converting
intention into action rather than a lack of awareness.
V. Discussion
The main conclusion from this research is that present bias, rather
than factors like loss aversion, mental accounting, overconfidence, or
self-control issues taken on their own, is the most significant and only valid
predictor of the amount saved by the respondents in this study. The findings
are surprising given that Mental Accounting and Self-Control Problems were
found to be less important than Present Bias and yet explain around 30% of the
variance in saving behavior. The results reflect the theory of hyperbolic
discounting introduced by Laibson in 1997 and indicate that even a medium level
of present bias can lead to the failure of saving behavior while being more
important than strong, but diffuse effect of Mental Accounting or Self-Control.
Almost half of the surveyed group (48.0%) that managed to put less
money away than expected, along with 45.7% of individuals who did not have an
adequate emergency fund, means that the gap between intention and actions seen
in behavioural economics literature is not just an oddity of the sample but a
reality experienced by the majority of the individuals surveyed, as well as by
a considerable portion of more affluent respondents (23.3%) who do not have an
appropriate emergency reserve even given the existing possibilities to
accumulate it. In other words, the results support the main thesis of the
research that the low levels of saving in India cannot be entirely explained by
income limitations alone, while they are in line with the idea of the
Behavioural life-cycle Hypothesis proposed by Shefrin and Thaler [6] suggesting
that saving is a continuous clash between planning and implementation instead
of just a rational calculation.
Demographic trends further clarify the situation. The high levels of
students' results in nearly every bias together with their large representation
in the sample shows that young people with limited means at the very beginning
of their financial lives are the most affected by the behaviourally vulnerable
group. The finding that loss aversion and self-control problems peak in the
36–45 age bracket, a life stage typically associated with larger financial
commitments, suggests that the dominant behavioural barrier to saving may shift
across the life course rather than remain constant, an implication that a
purely cross-sectional design can identify but not confirm causally.
Therefore, some caution is necessary in the case of non-significant
effects. With the very low reliability of the Overconfidence scale (α = .059),
its zero correlation with saving frequency should not be interpreted as
overconfidence being irrelevant behaviorally. Instead, the null correlation
probably signals the fact that the scale is subject to the measurement error
and it is therefore not a valid apparatus for measuring the phenomenon of
interest, leading to the conclusion that Loss Aversion, Mental Accounting, and
Self-Control Problems despite being fairly reliable might have various effects,
which prevent obtaining expected results.
A. Implications
Policymakers will distinctly benefit from current findings on the
relevance of using nudges as opposed to education-only approaches: automated
and voluntary joining of pension schemes increased participation from 55% to
87% in five years’ time following the Automatic Enrolment Pension Reform in the
UK, while opting out mandatory contributions to provident funds or the National
Pension System would emulate a low-resistance lever in India’s formal job
sector. Financial literacy initiatives should favor behavioural over mere
knowledge information since qualitative data reveal that many respondents have
been acquainted with financial practices but fail to implement their knowledge
in practice.
Moreover, for financial institutions saving products using mandatory
withdrawal restrictions would agree to the commitment concept, as products with
loss-oriented communications would suit clients demonstrated both present bias
and loss aversion. Financial advice would do well to consider the presence of
bias when advising clients by screening clients for signs of commitment bias
such as the gap between intentions and actual saving practices. Educational
establishments could see behavioural finance incorporated in a number of
courses targeted at providing students with necessary information, thus
intervening in biased behaviours.
VI. Limitations and Future Research
The study that was conducted comes with some limitations. The nature
of the research is such that it can only identify correlations rather than
establish one factor’s effect of the other. Also, participants’ self-reported
answers pose the risk of social-desirability bias, so it can also be said that
sampling across Gujarat has had some influence on the generalisability of
findings. Overconfidence scale used in the study is problematic, a more
appropriate instrument should be used in future research to measure
overconfidence. Finally, the research has not accounted for family structure,
marital situation or experience of financial shocks.
Future research should use either longitudinal or experimental
designs to identify the first cause and test the effectiveness of
interventions. For instance, panel studies that track saving behaviour over 1
to 3 years, as well as randomised field trials of opt-out enrolment, commitment
products and loss-framed messages, could be used. Research into saving
behaviour focusing on either high-income urban areas or mainly rural and poorer
states would improve generalisability. Structural equation modelling or path
analysis should be used to find out how five identified biases work together,
instead of working separately, whereas stratified by gender and income research
should find out whether nudges work differently depending on these
characteristics. Finally, since this research is made in the discipline of
forensic accounting; it should further investigate the relationship between
saving behaviour biases, such as the relationship between loss aversion and
informal savings or overconfidence and vulnerability to mis-sold financial
products, and the vulnerability to fraud, which is highly relevant from the
point of view of practical application.
VII. Conclusion
The research aimed to investigate the effect of five types of biases
on saving behaviour of 177 subjects in India. The results were unambiguous:
present bias is the leading behavioural hindrance; it accounts for roughly 30%
of the variations in saving frequency, whereas mental accounting and
self-control were prevalent in real life, but their statistical influence on
saving behaviour was weaker than in the case of present bias. In addition to
that, it is important to note that nearly 50% of the sample saved less than it
planned and almost 50% did not have enough savings for emergencies, regardless
of their income. All these findings corroborate the main assumption of this
research, i.e., under-saving in India is based on cognition and behaviour that
need to be taken into consideration when developing saving systems and
financial products.
📚
References
Psychology and economics: Evidence from the field
Golden eggs and hyperbolic discounting
Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk
Mental accounting and consumer choice
The behavioral life-cycle hypothesis
A Theory of the Consumption Function
Stochastic implications of the life cycle-permanent income hypothesis: Theory and evidence
Tying Odysseus to the mast: Evidence from a commitment savings product in the Philippines
Earmarking and partitioning: Increasing saving by low-income households
Financial literacy and retirement planning in the United States
Save more tomorrow: Using behavioral economics to increase employee saving
Why are saving rates of urban households in China rising?
⚖️
Ethics Declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Users can freely download, share, and reuse the article for any purpose (even commercially), as long as they give proper credit to the original author.
Competing Interests
Users can freely download and share the article, but they are strictly prohibited from using it or selling it for commercial profit.
Consent for Publication
Users can only read and view the article for personal use; they cannot copy, redistribute, or reuse any part of it without explicit permission from your journal.
📋
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailComplete editorial process — cryptographically verified
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailEditorial Process Audit Trail
NFSU-2026-V2-I1-J-2026-0028-CHAIN
✓ Verified · 8 blocks · Genesis 0x9f2bManuscript Received
20 Nov 2026 16:23
Passed Initial Screening
20 Nov 2026 16:24
Similarity Check Completed
20 Nov 2026 16:24
Editor Assigned
20 Nov 2026 16:34
Editor decision: Accepted
20 Nov 2026 16:34
Ready for Production
20 Nov 2026 17:05
Sent to Issue Manager
20 Nov 2026 17:09
Published Online
20 Nov 2026 17:31
🔐
Verification & Trust
CompliantCOPE · ICMJE · FAIR · ORCID · CLOCKSS
Verification & Trust
CompliantArticle Integrity Verified
All editorial chain blocks cryptographically verified · Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, and FAIR standards


