Methodological Issues in the Interrelation-ship Between the Commodity Characteris-tics of a Company's Property, Their Market Value and the Company's Capitalization
📄
Abstract
Abstract:
Because the determination of capitalization also requires the inclusion of risks arising from the qualitative condition of assets, it is necessary, within this logic, to introduce a risk-adjustment mechanism into the valuation model, whereby the commodity characteristics of assets are “transformed” into quantitative indices. These indices make it possible to introduce the concept of a “Commodity Risk Coefficient” into the process of determining property value. Its application in valuation models would allow qualitative uncertainties associated with assets to be taken into account and the calculated value to be brought closer to the company's actual economic potential, thereby establishing a stable relationship between the actual material and technical condition of assets and the organization's capitalization.
Drawing on the principles of systematic and scientifically grounded economic valuation, this article proposes the introduction of standardized procedures for integrated financial-economic and commodity expertise in order to reduce distortions in capitalization. The adoption of such procedures would prevent the market value of assets in major transactions and bankruptcy proceedings from being determined solely on the basis of financial reporting data, while requiring a commodity expertise assessment of the actual physical condition of the property.
🏷️
Keywords
📖
Full Article
I. Introduction
In today's economic environment, a company's capitalization and the
market value of its assets are often subject to speculative fluctuations. One
of the fundamental bases for determining a company's actual value is the
liquidity of its tangible assets and property, which directly derives from
their commodity characteristics.
In mergers, acquisitions, and particularly bankruptcy proceedings,
experts often rely exclusively on financial and accounting documents,
overlooking the actual physical, material, and operational characteristics of
the property. This practice may lead either to an overvaluation of assets (an
artificial increase in capitalization) or to an unjustified reduction in
property value (the disposal of assets in cases of deliberate bankruptcy). From
the perspective of forensic economic expertise, it is therefore essential to
understand the methodological process through which commodity characteristics
are “transformed” into market value and, consequently, influence a company's
overall capitalization.
II. Literature Review
The relationship between the commodity characteristics and their
economic value has been examined since the time of the classical economists. A.
Smith and K. Marx differentiated between the concepts of “use value” and
“exchange value”. In contemporary economics, Aswath Damodaran highlights that
asset valuation should be grounded in the assets’ actual capacity for value
creation [1], [2].
The International Valuation Standards (IVS 2022) specify that the
determination of market value requires an in-depth assessment of the physical
deterioration, functional obsolescence and economic obsolescence of property.
In this context, forensic economic expertise would be almost inevitably
incomplete without a comprehensive commodity analysis, since the documented
“price” and the physical “value” may differ significantly from one another [3],
[4].
III. Theoretical and Methodological Foundations
Contemporary corporate valuation theory is based on the premise that
a company's value depends not only on its expected future cash flows but also
on the level of risk associated with its assets. Asset-related risks are
directly reflected in the cost of capital and the discount rate used to
estimate corporate value. Contemporary valuation approaches make it possible to
incorporate non-financial risk factors into financial models through the use of
an additional risk premium [2].
International valuation practice recognizes that an asset's physical
and functional condition is a fundamental determinant of its economic value.
The International Valuation Standards establish that physical deterioration,
functional obsolescence, and economic obsolescence have a significant impact on
asset value and must be taken into account in both business valuation and fixed
asset valuation processes [3].
The theoretical foundation of risk-adjusted valuation is rooted in
the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), according to which the expected return
on an investment consists of the risk-free rate plus a risk premium.
Contemporary financial research has extended this framework by introducing
additional sources of risk, including size, liquidity and country risk
premiums. These developments provide a methodological basis for incorporating
risks arising from the qualitative characteristics of assets into valuation
models [5].
The relationship between the technical condition of assets and the
economic value they generate is also supported by contemporary economic
research on valuation, according to which the operational reliability of assets
directly affects the stability of future cash flows. Technical uncertainties
and operational risks gradually transform into value-related risks over time,
reducing the company’s overall market value [6].
Commodity science further demonstrates that the qualitative
characteristics of tangible assets serve as one of the fundamental determinants
in the formation of economic value. The quality, reliability, functional
suitability and operational efficiency of products and technical equipment
directly determine their market demand and value-creation potential, which
requires the integration of qualitative indicators into the economic valuation
process [7].
Nevertheless, financial and economic research shows that a distorted
assessment of the actual value of assets can lead to an incorrect
interpretation of an organization’s financial condition and even to the
creation of situations of artificial bankruptcy. The inadequate or unrealistic
reflection of asset values in financial statements causes deviations in
capitalization indicators and leads to an inaccurate assessment of investment
risks [8].
IV. Analysis
In practice, within the framework of economic activities, a number
of systematic discrepancies often arise between the accounting valuation of a
company’s property assets and their actual market values, which have a
significant impact on the objective assessment of the company’s capitalization.
From the perspective of the gap between the market value of assets
and the company’s overall capitalization, the main issues can be classified and
formulated as follows:
• Overvaluation for the
purpose of attracting financing
In cases where a company seeks to attract credit resources or
increase the market price of its shares, the balance sheet often reflects the
initial or revalued value of property without considering technical,
operational, or qualitative hidden deficiencies identified through commodity
expertise. As a result, an overestimated picture of the economic potential of
the assets is formed, which does not reflect their actual market liquidity. For
forensic examination purposes, it is important to distinguish between highly
liquid and illiquid assets, because the adjustment coefficients applied to
their values differ significantly.
• Undervaluation during
asset revaluation processes in cases of intentional bankruptcy
In cases of deliberate bankruptcy, under conditions of unfair
management, it is possible to artificially reduce the qualitative
characteristics of assets by presenting them as defective or economically
unusable property. Such practices aim to ensure the disposal of assets at
prices significantly below their market value, often in favor of related
parties, which leads to the illegal redistribution of the company’s capital.
• Undervaluation resulting
from the impact of depreciation accounting policies
Within the framework of the company’s accounting policies, the
absence of fixed asset revaluation may lead to a gradual distortion of the
actual value of assets. In particular, the carrying value of assets is
continuously reduced through depreciation charges until reaching a zero
residual value, while their actual economic usefulness and “potential” under
real market conditions may remain preserved.
• Undervaluation due to the
disregard of moral (technological) obsolescence
In practice, situations often arise in which the physical condition
of an asset is assessed as satisfactory or even good, yet technological
progress and market changes cause the asset to lose its economic relevance. In
such cases, the property continues to be reflected on the balance sheet at a
high value based solely on its physical condition, whereas, from the
perspective of capitalization, it has already lost its competitiveness in terms
of market demand. As a result, an “apparent economic strength” of the assets is
created that does not correspond to actual market conditions.
• Undervaluation in cases
of impaired asset composition and functional compatibility
A company’s capitalization is formed not through the mechanical sum
of individual assets, but on the basis of their technological and operational
interrelationships. In practice, situations may arise where individual assets
have high commodity characteristics, but technological incompatibility between
them or disruption of the production chain reduces the efficiency of the entire
asset complex and, consequently, the company’s overall market value.
The results of the study indicate that, within the operation of
modern financial markets and especially in the context of bankruptcy
proceedings, there is often an artificial disconnect between the actual
commodity characteristics of property assets and their accounting (balance
sheet) values. Such discrepancies lead to a distorted assessment of the
company’s actual economic potential and market capitalization, creating a
non-objective representation of asset value, which in turn results in the
unlawful redistribution of capital.
In this context, it is appropriate to introduce “standardized and
mandatory mechanisms for comprehensive commodity and financial-economic expert
assessment of property valuation,” which should be implemented on the basis of
unified, accepted regulations. Such an approach would help reduce the risks of
intentional or methodologically “directed” (resulting from the selective
application of valuation tools) overvaluation and undervaluation of assets. At
the same time, it is proposed to limit the determination of the market value of
assets in major economic transactions, restructuring, and bankruptcy
proceedings solely on the basis of financial reporting data. Instead, a
mandatory commodity inspection and expert assessment of the actual physical
condition of the property should be carried out to ensure an objective
reflection of the assets’ actual economic utility, technical condition, and
market liquidity.
The application of the proposed mechanism will contribute to greater
transparency in capitalization assessment, reduced investment risks and, from
the perspective of comprehensive commodity and financial-economic expertise,
stronger scientific substantiation of the results obtained.
Thus, the economic essence of an organization’s capitalization
reflects the company’s overall economic potential, investment attractiveness
and ability to create value in the market. From an economic perspective,
capitalization represents the net value remaining for owners after the market
valuation of the company’s assets, under the condition of settling its
liabilities. As is well known, the fundamental economic relationship of
capitalization can be presented by the following equation:
(1)
where:
CAP – the company’s
capitalization (the market value of its equity);
MVassets – the market
value of the company’s assets (the main factor determining the organization’s
value);
Liabilities – the total
value of the company’s liabilities.
This equation is based on the fundamental principle of corporate
finance, according to which the value of an organization is allocated between
creditors and shareholders [9]. Simultaneously, in market conditions,
capitalization may also be expressed through the market valuation of
shareholders’ equity, where the company’s net assets correspond to the total
market value of its shares outstanding, according to the following equation
[2].
(2)
where:
Pshare – the market price
of one share;
Nshares – the number of
shares outstanding.
This approach is widely applied in the valuation of public companies
and is reflected in modern corporate finance theory [10].
With regard to the market value of a share, it is known that, from a
theoretical perspective, it can be presented in at least two dimensions:
1. Exchange value
(simplified approach)
Under this approach, the market value of a share is the price at
which the security is bought and sold on the stock exchange at a given moment.
The price is formed as a result of the interaction between supply and demand
and reflects investors’ current expectations, the information environment, and
market sentiment. Therefore, the stock market price may often differ from the
company’s actual economic value, which is determined by the following
relationship:
(3)
2. Definition of intrinsic
value
In this case, according to the principles of the classical school of
thought developed by Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett, the true value of a
stock is defined as the present value of the future cash flows that the company
is expected to generate. This approach is based on the discounted cash flow
(DCF) methodology, according to which the value of an asset is determined by
its ability to generate income rather than merely by its current market price.
This relationship can be expressed as follows [11], [12]:
(4)
where:
CFt –
represents the future cash flows;
r – is the discount rate;
t – is the time period.
However, it is generally accepted that for companies with high
property intensity (such as manufacturing, construction, transportation, and
infrastructure organizations), the value creation process is determined not
primarily by the turnover of financial assets, but by the actual market
condition of tangible assets. For such companies, the fundamental relationship
for estimating capitalization can be presented as follows:
(5)
where:
V – represents the actual
market value of all company assets (the property complex);
L – represents the
company’s total liabilities;
n – represents the number
of shares outstanding.
This relationship effectively represents the net economic value
attributable to one share and is particularly applicable when valuing
capital-intensive business entities.
Classical financial approaches to determining the value of property
assets are primarily based on accounting or income-based indicators. However,
in companies where tangible assets constitute the dominant share of total
assets, the value of these assets is directly determined by their
commodity-related characteristics.
Within the framework of this approach, it is proposed to define
value through the functional relationship of
“commodity characteristics”,
according to which V (the value of
assets) is directly proportional to Q
(the commodity quality):
(6)
or, in
simplified form: V:Q
where:
Q – the product quality
(quality characteristics);
t – the technical
condition;
m – the degree of
depreciation (physical and moral/functional obsolescence);
s – the market demand
(marketability/liquidity).
Regarding the concept of “Quality,” it should be noted that it is a
multifaceted category with philosophical, technical, and economic dimensions.
From a philosophical perspective, it reflects the identity of an object and its
distinguishing characteristics, while in the economic context it is viewed as a
cornerstone in shaping consumer value and market demand [13].
At the applied and expert level, quality is interpreted in the
following ways:
• fitness
for use;
• fulfillment
of intended needs;
• compliance
with established standards and regulations;
• meeting
consumer expectations;
• maintaining
a level consistent with the dynamics of market demand.
These criteria demonstrate that quality is not merely a static
objective characteristic but also contains a subjective component determined by
consumer perception.
The market values of property assets are the result of the combined
influence of their physicochemical and structural characteristics, operational
reliability, and degree of depreciation. Within the process of commodity
expertise, these factors are transformed into quantitative indices and
integrated into valuation and capitalization models, functioning simultaneously
as value-creating and risk-generating factors.
The methodological basis of the above is that the value of assets is
determined not by their accounting (book) value, but by their actual
suitability for use. The latter is defined by the material’s strength,
durability, corrosion resistance, and structural integrity. These parameters
are precisely what shape the asset’s operational reliability and its remaining
useful life at the specific point of measurement.
At the stage of determining actual suitability, the first
“transformation” takes place, namely the conversion of physical reality into
economic expectations.
The depreciation factor has a key impact on the formation of asset
value. Having a multi-component structure, it is defined as the degree of
deterioration or loss of product properties, which is subject to quantitative
assessment [14].
Commodity expertise is the key scientific and practical mechanism
through which the second “transformation” is carried out, namely the conversion
of qualitative characteristics into quantitative indicators.
As a result of the assessment, indices are developed for the
respective property, reflecting:
1. loss
of quality;
2. the
level of depreciation;
3. reduction
in value.
When incorporated into economic calculations, these indices form the
integrated commodity quality of the property, which serves as the direct basis
for determining its market value.
This theoretical concept finds its practical application in the
step-by-step algorithm of commodity expertise, which ensures a clear transition
from the “commodity characteristic” to the “loss of quality.” The step-by-step
algorithm of commodity expertise consists of the following stages:
Stage 1. Identification of the object and determination of baseline data
The object under examination is identified, and the initial value,
actual period of use, and standard service life are established.
Stage 2. Expert examination of the physical and qualitative condition
The condition of the material, structural integrity, appearance and
functional suitability are analyzed. The expert evaluates the actual condition
of the object and the impact of damages on its consumer properties.
Stage 3. Differentiation of depreciation types
Physical wear, obsolescence, and defect-related factors are
identified separately, which helps avoid aggregated assessments that may be
methodologically inaccurate.
Stage 4. Calculation of normative (time-based) wear
It is determined based on the number of years the property (product)
has been in use and the annual normative depreciation rate established for that
type of property, using the following formula:
(7)
where:
R – the loss of quality
expressed in value resulting from depreciation;
P – the initial (or
replacement) value;
K – the number of years of
service;
H – the annual normative
depreciation rate (percentage).
Stage 5. Assessment of the impact of defects
Standardized methodological tables are used to convert the
identified types of damage into specific percentages of quality loss [15].
Stage 6. Synthesis of the overall depreciation level
The time-based and defect-related components are combined to
establish a comprehensive indicator of the property's loss of quality.
However, as an important methodological consideration, it should be
noted that the proposed algorithm is limited to internal factors only—namely,
physical and functional depreciation, as well as defects—while excluding
external or economic depreciation. The latter results from macroeconomic
changes in the market environment, legislative restrictions, or industry shifts
that may significantly reduce the consumer demand for an asset, irrespective of
its actual technical condition. In addition, the linear calculation formula
applied in Stage 4 assumes a uniform rate of depreciation over time, whereas,
in practice, the qualitative degradation of assets is often non-linear or
occurs in discrete increments, depending on the intensity of use. Therefore, to
ensure the highest possible degree of objectivity in forensic expert
conclusions, the methodology should also incorporate an index reflecting
external depreciation arising from prevailing market conditions, as well as
non-linear degradation models. This comprehensive enhancement would help
prevent distortions in the capitalization rate used in economic calculations,
particularly under conditions of high uncertainty and economic volatility.
Thus, the above approach demonstrates that commodity expertise
serves as a ‘’transformational’’ link between material reality and economic
valuation, ensuring the objective assessment of asset value. At the same time,
it reveals the dual nature of value—as a function of quality and as an
expression of risk. This concept makes it possible to incorporate market value
into capitalization models as a risk-adjusted indicator, which, in turn, can
serve as the basis for determining the company's actual market value.
The market value of assets is determined not only by their
existence, but also by their operational efficiency and market applicability.
Based on the above theoretical provisions, the following integrated
economic model for capitalization is proposed.
(8)
where:
Q – commodity quality;
L – liquidity;
D – depreciation;
P – profitability;
βi – the
coefficients representing the intensity of the influence of the respective
factors.
In the model, the parameter α
represents the initial (baseline) level of capitalization (α = CAPbas). Specifically, it reflects factors such as the market
environment, brand value, management quality, institutional trust,
macroeconomic conditions, industry positioning, and investment expectations,
all of which are determined by structural or systemic factors not explicitly
incorporated into the model. Accordingly, α represents the autonomous component
of capitalization that cannot be explained by the commodity-related or
financial-economic indicators of the assets.
By contrast, the parameter ε
denotes the random disturbance or econometric error term, that is, the
difference between the actual capitalization and the value estimated by the
model (in econometric terms, ε = CAPreal
− CAPmodel). It encompasses measurement errors, unpredictable market
fluctuations, information asymmetry, investors' behavioral factors, short-term
shocks, and the subjectivity inherent in the valuation process.
The proposed model makes it possible to integrate financial and
commodity-related factors into the capitalization assessment process, thereby
providing a multifactor economic explanation of an organization's value. This
is particularly important for asset-intensive business entities.
The above model implies that an organization's capitalization is
determined by the combined effect of the commodity-related and
financial-economic characteristics of its assets, with the market value of
those assets effectively functioning as a function of their qualitative
condition. However, the process of value formation alone does not ensure the
sustainability of that value, since the technical, physical, and operational
characteristics of assets are not only value-generating factors but also sources
of risk.
Consequently, the assessment of capitalization cannot be limited to
calculating value relationships alone; it also requires the incorporation of
risks arising from the qualitative condition of the assets. This reasoning
necessitates a transition from a value determination model to a risk-adjustment
mechanism, under which the commodity-related characteristics of assets are
transformed into a valuation risk factor. Such a methodological extension is
achieved through the introduction of an additional risk premium—the “Commodity
Risk Premium (CRP)”—which makes it possible to establish a relationship between
the actual physical and technical condition of the assets and the economic
sustainability of the organization's capitalization.
In the framework of this study, the concept of risk is based on the
premise that the commodity-related characteristics of assets not only determine
their market value but also influence the risk associated with the stability
and preservation of that value over time.
Within the integrated capitalization model, given that the
commodity-related condition of assets simultaneously affects both their value
and the risk profile of that value, it is appropriate to express an
organization's capitalization as the following risk-adjusted relationship:
(9)
where:
CAP* – the organization's
risk-adjusted capitalization (Risk-Adjusted Capitalization);
CRP – the risk premium
arising from the commodity-related condition of the assets (Commodity Risk
Premium).
The Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) is calculated as follows:
(10)
where k
is the empirical coefficient of industry-specific risk sensitivity.
The concept of the risk premium, in this context, is based on the
following rationale:
(11)
This formula reflects the adjustment of asset value according to the
logic of risk discounting, whereby CRP is added to the base risk rate.
To convert the qualitative and technical characteristics t, m, s, and reliability of the assets
into a quantitative indicator, the weighted-average method is used (on a scale
from 0 to 1, where 1.0 represents a perfectly faultless condition):
(12)
where:
• t – the technical condition (accumulated
physical depreciation from past use);
• m – the commodity/material
characteristics (quality of materials, completeness, and compliance with
standards);
• s – operational safety and degree of
preservation;
• reliability – reliability (expected
residual service life and risk of failure);
• wt, wm, ws, wr – the respective weights
of the variables (Σw = 1.0).
In the above formula, the variables t (technical condition) and reliability
are closely interrelated from both economic and technical perspectives (if the
technical condition is poor, reliability is also low). It should be noted,
however, that t, m, s, and reliability
are treated as independent structural components (for example, t reflects
accumulated past depreciation, whereas reliability reflects the expected
residual service life). As noted above, k
is an empirical/industry-specific coefficient determined by the average risk
level of the relevant industry (for example, by analogy with the CAPM beta coefficient), or through
expert surveys and regression analysis of historical data.
Numerical Example of the Calculation of the Commodity Risk Premium
(CRP):
1. Initial data for the valuation object
• Valuation
object: the company's main production line.
• Initial
book value (V): AMD 100,000,000.
• Industry
risk-sensitivity coefficient (k): 0.30 (adopted on the basis of historical
industry data and regression analysis for industrial equipment).
Results of the commodity expertise assessment (on a scale from 0 to
1):
• t
(technical condition): 0.60 (actual depreciation is 40%; preservation is 60%);
weight wt = 0.35.
• m
(commodity characteristic): 0.75 (completeness and conformity of material
quality); weight wm = 0.20.
• s
(safety): 0.70 (operational safety and preservation conditions); weight ws
= 0.20.
• reliability:
0.50 (forecast residual working life); weight wr = 0.25.
• Total
sum of weights: 1.00.
2. Step-by-step numerical calculation
Step 1. Calculation of the integrated quality index (Iqual)
Iqual = (0.35 *
0.60) + (0.20 * 0.75) + (0.20 * 0.70) + (0.25 * 0.50)
Iqual = 0.210 +
0.150 + 0.140 + 0.125 = 0.625 (or 62.5%)
Step 2. Calculation of the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP)
CRP = 0.30 * (1 - 0.625) =
0.30 * 0.375 = 0.1125 (or 11.25%)
Result: The asset's incomplete qualitative/technical condition
generates an additional risk premium of 11.25%.
Step 3. Calculation of risk-adjusted actual capitalization (CAP*)
CAP* = 100,000,000 / (1 +
0.1125) = 100,000,000 / 1.1125 = 89,887,640 AMD
3. Comparative analysis of the results
• Without
CRP (based solely on accounting data):
CAP = AMD 100,000,000.
• With
CRP applied (adjusted actual value):
CAP* = AMD 89,887,640.
• Deviation:
+AMD 10,112,360 (+10.11%).
Conclusion: If the valuation were performed exclusively on the basis
of financial statements, without an actual commodity expertise assessment, the
company's capitalization would be overvalued by 10.11% (approximately AMD 10.11
million). The introduction of CRP makes it possible to neutralize this
distortion, thereby improving the accuracy and economic realism of forensic
economic analysis, bankruptcy proceedings, and creditworthiness assessment.
For the integrated capitalization model, because the commodity
condition simultaneously affects both the value of assets and the risk
associated with that value, capitalization should be presented in risk-adjusted
form:
(13)
where:
CAP – the risk-adjusted
capitalization.
This equation demonstrates that:
If the quality of the
assets is high:
• the
CRP decreases because the risks of operational failures, repair costs,
technological obsolescence, and cash flow volatility perceived by investors are
reduced;
• capitalization
increases.
If depreciation is
substantial, the technology is obsolete, or reliability is low:
• the
CRP increases;
• the
risk-adjusted capitalization decreases.
Accordingly, it should be concluded that an improvement in asset
quality reduces the risk adjustment, resulting in an increase in risk-adjusted
capitalization.
A fundamental economic implication of the foregoing is that the
commodity expertise of assets is transformed into a significant financial and
economic factor influencing the formation of an organization's capitalization.
Thus, the commodity-related characteristics of a company's assets,
the market value derived from those characteristics and the organization's
overall capitalization together constitute an integrated economic system in
which each component determines the objectivity of the others. The qualitative,
technical and operational condition of the property assets serves as the
primary basis for the company's actual economic value, while the financial
reflection of these characteristics constitutes a determining factor in the
formation of capitalization.
Studies indicate that discrepancies between accounting records and
the actual commodity-related condition of assets lead to systematic distortions
in a company's value. Such discrepancies become particularly pronounced in the
context of major transactions, corporate reorganizations, and bankruptcy
proceedings, where asset valuation is often carried out without a comprehensive
expert assessment of their actual physical condition. As a result, artificial
changes in capitalization may arise, creating opportunities for financial
manipulation, the unlawful redistribution of assets and the risk of deliberate
insolvency.
With regard to the localization of international methodological
approaches to corporate valuation and capitalization assessment, particularly
in the context of the Republic of Armenia and other regional economies, it is
first necessary to consider the feasibility of introducing the above-mentioned
additional adjustment instrument—the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP).
This premium may be incorporated into company valuation models to
account for the risks arising from the physical condition, technical
reliability, degree of depreciation and functional adequacy of fixed assets.
The proposed approach makes it possible to incorporate qualitative
uncertainties associated with assets into capitalization
calculations—uncertainties that are not ordinarily fully reflected in financial
statements or in conventional valuation models. As a result, the estimated
value of a company would be adjusted not only on the basis of its financial
indicators but also in light of the actual commodity-related condition and
operational reliability of its property assets.
Accordingly, it is evident that, in contemporary corporate valuation
theory, a company's capitalization is determined not only by projected
financial flows and the risk associated with the market environment, but also
by the actual economic usefulness of its production and property assets.
However, traditional international valuation models (DCF, EVA, Market
Multiples, etc.) are based primarily on accounting and financial data and do
not adequately reflect risks arising from the commodity-related condition of
assets.
When applied, the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) should serve as an
integrated valuation-adjustment indicator that quantitatively reflects
value-related risk arising from the qualitative, technical, and operational
uncertainties associated with a company's fixed and tangible assets. It should
capture the potential economic loss that may result from physical depreciation,
technological obsolescence, operational limitations, or reduced operational
reliability of those assets.
The methodology for deriving the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) is
based on a multifactor assessment principle and comprises the following
sequential stages:
1. Commodity-related
diagnosis of assets. An expert assessment of fixed assets is carried out to
determine:
• the
degree of physical depreciation;
• technical
condition and reliability;
• technological
modernity;
• intensity
of use;
• inadequate
maintenance costs;
• functional
suitability for production purposes.
2. Normalization of risk
indicators
Each indicator is converted into a comparable quantitative index
(within the 0–1 range), where 1 corresponds to an optimal condition, while 0
represents a condition close to economic obsolescence or unusability.
3. Formation of a weighting
system
Weights are assigned to the indicators based on their economic
significance, taking into account the asset's impact on the income-generating
process. For example, in manufacturing companies, technical reliability may be
assigned a higher weight than external physical deterioration.
4. Calculation of the
integrated commodity risk index
A composite indicator characterizing the overall qualitative
condition of the assets is obtained, reflecting the level of operational risk.
5. Transformation of risk
into a value adjustment coefficient
The resulting index is incorporated into the valuation model:
• either
as an additional component of the discount rate;
• or
as an adjustment reduction coefficient applied to the company's calculated
value.
Theoretically, the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) may be expressed
according to the following general principle:
(14)
where:
F – represents physical
depreciation, technical condition, reliability, technological modernity,
inadequate maintenance costs, and functional suitability;
CRP – expresses the
additional risk premium arising from the qualitative condition of the assets.
It should be noted that, from the perspective of applicability, the
proposed methodological approach is particularly important under the conditions
of transitional and developing economies, where the book value of assets often
differs significantly from their actual economic value.
The incorporation of the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) into the
capitalization assessment process makes it possible to combine financial and
physical factors, thereby providing a more objective, scientifically grounded
and investment-reliable evaluation of a company's value.
V. Conclusion and Recommendations
Thus, the Commodity Risk Premium (CRP) serves as a bridging
mechanism between financial valuation models and the actual commodity-related
condition of assets, ensuring the economic realism of corporate value
calculations and the comprehensive consideration of potential risks. From a
methodological perspective, it is based on the international theory of
corporate valuation, risk-adjusted return assessment models, particularly the
approaches developed within the framework of the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM),
as well as the theoretical principles of risk premiums developed by William
Sharpe in 1964 and Aswath Damodaran in 2012.
The proposed concept of the Commodity Risk Premium has been
developed as a result of a comparative analysis of international theoretical
approaches in corporate valuation and asset assessment. At the same time, the
proposed approach is also consistent with the principles established in the
International Valuation Standards (IVS, 2022) regarding the assessment of the
physical condition, technical depreciation, and functional suitability of
assets.
As previously discussed, an objective assessment of a company's
value is possible only through the integration of financial-economic and
commodity-related approaches. The assessment of physical depreciation,
technological modernity, functional comparability, and market liquidity of
assets should be considered not as auxiliary elements, but as mandatory
components of valuation methodology. In this context, the proposed
comprehensive commodity-related and financial-economic expert assessment will
make it possible to ensure transparency in capitalization valuation, reduce
investment and legal risks, and enhance the scientific validity and practical
effectiveness of comprehensive commodity-related and financial-economic
examinations. At the same time, the application of the Commodity Risk Premium
in valuation models will allow qualitative uncertainties of assets to be taken
into account, bringing the calculated value closer to the company's actual
economic potential.
It should also be emphasized that the application of this
methodology ensures a comprehensive assessment of risks and prevents potential
systemic errors in the calculation of capitalization rates within subsequent
economic analyses. As a result, a methodologically justified value
determination mechanism is formed, which is particularly applicable within the
framework of forensic economic and forensic commodity examinations, including
investigations of intentional bankruptcy proceedings, determination of the
actual value of company shares and businesses, as well as the assessment of
investment risks and creditworthiness. This approach makes it possible to
eliminate the influence of subjective factors and minimize the risks of
undervaluation of the capitalization coefficient.
Therefore, an accurate determination of an organization's
capitalization is possible only when financial indicators are combined with the
actual commodity-related condition of property assets, creating a comprehensive
and scientifically balanced system of economic valuation.
Based on the approaches and principles outlined above, in order to prevent distortions in capitalization, it is also proposed to introduce a mandatory procedure for conducting comprehensive financial-economic and commodity-related expert examinations. This procedure should aim to prevent the undervaluation or overvaluation of property assets and, at the same time, exclude the determination of the market value of company assets solely on the basis of accounting data, by prioritizing an expert assessment of the actual condition of the property.
🖼️
Figures & Tables
📚
References
Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium
Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy
The Wealth of Nations
Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset
International Valuation Standards (IVS)
Судебно-экономическая экспертиза и товароведение: точки пересечения при банкротстве
Valuation of Intellectual Property and Intangible Assets
Juran's Quality Handbook
Principles of Corporate Finance
Corporate Finance
The Intelligent Investor
The Superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville
Ապրանքի (արտադրանքի) որակ հասկացությունը, հսկողությունը և համապատասխանության ստուգումը դատաապրանքագիտական փորձաքննությունների շրջանակում
Розрахунок втрати якості непродовольчих товарів у зв'язку з їх зносом та наявністю дефектів, який використовується при проведенні товарознавчих досліджень
Таблица определения степени снижения качества (и стоимости) имущества, принадлежащего физическим лицам
⚖️
Ethics Declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Users can freely download, share, and reuse the article for any purpose (even commercially), as long as they give proper credit to the original author.
Competing Interests
Users can freely download and share the article, but they are strictly prohibited from using it or selling it for commercial profit.
Consent for Publication
Users can only read and view the article for personal use; they cannot copy, redistribute, or reuse any part of it without explicit permission from your journal.
📋
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailComplete editorial process — cryptographically verified
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailEditorial Process Audit Trail
NFSU-2026-V2-I1-J-2026-0029-CHAIN
✓ Verified · 8 blocks · Genesis 0x9f2bManuscript Received
20 Nov 2026 16:30
Passed Initial Screening
20 Nov 2026 16:31
Similarity Check Completed
20 Nov 2026 16:31
Editor Assigned
20 Nov 2026 16:34
Editor decision: Accepted
20 Nov 2026 16:35
Ready for Production
20 Nov 2026 17:10
Sent to Issue Manager
20 Nov 2026 17:18
Published Online
20 Nov 2026 17:31
🔐
Verification & Trust
CompliantCOPE · ICMJE · FAIR · ORCID · CLOCKSS
Verification & Trust
CompliantArticle Integrity Verified
All editorial chain blocks cryptographically verified · Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, and FAIR standards