📄
Abstract
Abstract: Bank fraud remains a serious challenge, reducing public trust and undermining the stability of financial institutions and reporting a rise in the frequency and value of fraud cases. This study seeks to understand how strong corporate governance can work as a shield for the banking sectors against fraud, by understanding the Fraud Triangle Framework which states that fraud is a result of pressure, opportunity and rationalization. Through an extensive literature review and real case studies from the Indian banking sector, the research explores how tools like independent boards, strict internal controls, ethical leadership and active audit committees can make a huge impact on the occurrence and detection of frauds. It can be analyzed that the banks with stronger governance systems are in a better position to detect the fraud risk with help of early warning signs, closing loopholes in the system and are building a culture where integrity gets prioritised. Overall the research reflects that the regulators play an important role in supporting governance and ensuring prevention of fraud in terms of national and international standards & aligning to the advancing technology. Aligning governance frameworks with human behaviour as per the fraud triangle will help banks in managing fraud risks and maintain trust and efficiency in the finance industry for the long term. Thus strong governance practices combined with behavioral understanding of fraud can help build safer and more accountable financial systems.
📖
Full Article
I. Introduction
“What happens when trust, the foundation of banking, crumbles under
the weight of rampant fraud? Can corporate governance genuinely be an
antidote?”
The financial sector, particularly banking, serves as the backbone
of the economy by facilitating financial transactions, providing credit and
promoting economic growth. It is one of the extremely significant components of
an economy. It performs a crucial part in the socioeconomic matters of the
nation. With the benefit this sector provides to the economy through its
development over the period, it also has become more prone to fraudulent acts
that weaken public confidence, disrupt financial stability, and cause immense
economic losses. Banking frauds and scandals highlight the weakness in
governance structure and regulatory oversights, necessitating stronger
mechanisms to ensure accountability and prevent financial misconduct. High
Profile bank fraud instances in India like the infamous Punjab National Bank
and Yes Bank scam have raised concerns about weak governance and regulation.
Corporate Governance is the structures and procedures by which an
organisation is directed and controlled. It serves as a foundation for ethical
business practices, financial transparency, and stakeholder trust. It is
important in the sense that it maintains the confidence of investors, complies
with the regulations and carries out ethical business activities. Corporate
Governance helps the organizations to formulate a clear and optimal policy,
maintain transparency by disclosing all material facts and establish an
efficient internal control system. Thus, Corporate governance has a major
significance in the banking sector. It enhances financial stability, promotes
transparency, ensures regulatory compliance, facilitates efficient capital
allocation and mitigates fraud risks. By integrating such corporate governance
practices in the banking sector it can help to strengthen their structure,
increase the trust among the stakeholders and contribute positively to economic
growth.
Besides lack of governance, banking frauds also point the necessity
to combat the kind of fraud which arises based on theoretical constructs such
as Fraud Triangle Theory propounded by criminologist Donald Cressey, which
asserts that the pressure (motivation), opportunity (means to commit fraud) and
rationalisation (justifications for committing an unethical act) are the three
reasons contributing to the happening of fraud.
When we look from the fraud triangle perspective it provides a
comprehensive lens for understanding how unethical behaviour originates in
complex organisations like banks where everything is under strict compliance
and regulations. According to fraud triangle theory the financial pressure may
arise from personal obligations, targets, profit motives. Opportunities in
cases of banking sector frauds are created by lack of internal controls and
inadequate monitoring and the culture that allows individuals to rationalize
unethical behavior leads to the risk of fraud.
This study tells how effective corporate governance practices in
terms of the fraud triangle theory to mitigate frauds, which can include
methods to reduce pressure through
ethical leadership, limiting the opportunities
leading to the increasing number of frauds by strict internal control in
which proper rule and regulations are followed, and use of accountability
measures which includes transparent reporting, effective risk management, etc
to counter rationalization. In terms
of looking through motives for why people do fraud, there does fraud triangle
theory "triggers" come handy, which is the three elements of fraud
that is, pressure, opportunity and rationalization.
Thus this research focuses on explaining how combining the fraud
triangle perspective with the corporate governance activities will help
mitigate frauds in the banking sector and they will be detected before their
occurrence.
Corporate governance and fraud prevention are two interconnected
terms that have significant effect on the operational integrity and
sustainability in banking sector. In recent years the banking sector became an
important pillar of the economy in terms of economic growth, financial
stability and public trust. However, the increase in the number of frauds in
the banking industry over the period reveals that the corporate governance
structure has been found wanting resulting in more frequent frauds in the economy.
All these financial frauds in the banking sector is a big question mark on the
effectiveness of the corporate governance and demands for changes in the
corporate governance structure to safeguard the stakeholders interest and
prevent fraudulent activities.
This research is significant for several reasons. It addresses the
impact on the economy, as a weak corporate governance structure in banks leads
to frauds in the banks which erodes the trust of customers/public, and the
economic development of the nation. Here's where a well-functioning corporate
structure becomes relevant now to rebuild trust and to do the right behaviour
in running banks. It mentions that the fraud triangle perspective is that the
application of the fraud triangle framework – pressure, opportunity, and
rationalization assists in comprehending and having a structured manner in
analyzing frauds of why or what is the reason behind the fraudulent behaviour
of any individual or person and finding a solution which would be suitable to
content to minimize the future likelihood of frauds. It addresses the
importance of regulations. The Reserve Bank of India already provides various
regulations to ensure effective corporate governance but still gaps remain
which lead to fraudulent activities. Thus this shows the need to frame
corporate governance structure in a way that detection of any fraud prior to
their occurrence is possible other than the prevention aspect which will reduce
the number of frauds and fraud risk. It aims towards practical implications to
corporate governance of the frameworks like fraud triangle which are really
helpful in analyzing the fraudulent behaviour and help in the detection of
fraudulent activities. It will offer recommendations for banks, regulators and
policymakers to enhance the governance practices by integrating frameworks from
forensic accounting like fraud triangle theory, fraud diamond etc which focuses
on understanding the reason behind the fraud, impact of accounting and
non-accounting decisions on detection methods.
II. Literature Review
This study aims to synthesize and understand existing academic
literature about corporate governance roles discussed above. It also includes
the fraud triangle theory perspective, how from this theory the corporate
governance mechanism can be enhanced by analysing the pressure, opportunity and
rationalisation behind the frauds and reducing the risk of fraud. The aim is to
establish theoretical and factual context for this study, identify research
gaps, and build a conceptual framework that helps in better understanding.
Before understanding corporate governance and fraud triangle theory
it is important to understand the fundamental concept of fraud which seems to
have accelerated in last few years especially occupational frauds and financial
frauds. Occupational fraud occurs when one uses their occupation and
obligations for personal gain, making self benefit use of position in misuse of
the authorities capacity including the committed fraudulence of the
organization resources. According to Merriam Webster's Dictionary of Law (1996)
as quoted in Abdullahi & Mansor [1], fraud is“Any act, expression, omission
or concealment that is calculated to deceive another to his or her
disadvantage, Specifically, a misrepresentation or concealment with reference
to some fact material to a transaction that is made with knowledge of its
falsity or in reckless disregard of its truth or falsity and with the intent to
deceive another and that is reasonably relied on by the other who is injured.”
Fraud according to corporate auditor is a conscious act done by an entity who
knows that such act can make him have possession of gain of illegitimate
manner. Fraud alternatively is the purposeful distortion, concealment and
disregard of a fact.
A. Review of
Relevant Literature and Theoretical Frameworks
Bank Corporate Governance: Shield against fraud - is one of the most
relevant literature for this research as it highlights how governance
mechanisms contribute in prevention of fraud. An efficient Corporate governance
system significantly reduces fraud risk in banks and for maintaining financial
stability, boosting stakeholder confidence, corporate accountability which is
done by ensuring transparency, accountability and ethical code of conduct in
the banks. As per Kulmie & Ibrahim [2], mechanisms such as board oversight,
audit and risk committees, remuneration systems, and compliance units are
instrumental in deterring fraudulent activities. The financial crimes occurring
in banks are committed by professionals which differs from crimes that take
place due to poverty, thus these crimes taking place inside the banking
institution come under white collar crime.
So it is important to understand the reason behind the fraud in
which fraud triangle theory is a theoretical aspect which identifies pressure,
opportunity and rationalisation are the elements that help in understanding the
reason for fraud being done by fraudsters; this theory was developed after
interviewing 250 criminals. The pressure may be personal, work or external
pressure based on external factors like greed, social issues and financial
difficulties and it can also be seen as what is termed personal and
institutional pressure. Due to pressure individuals seek for opportunity to
commit fraud and the opportunity arises due lack of control and governance
inadequacy. Whereas rationalization is the justification for unethical
behaviour done because of some pressure. In addition to the fraud triangle
theory, agency theory and institutional theory explain the conditions that lead
to fraud in the organisations. Integration of the theoretical constructs of the
Fraud Triangle Theory, Agency Theory and Institutional Theory, provide
analytical lens of examination in this paper. The theories explain the
underlying drivers of fraudulent behavior, such as pressure, opportunity, and
rationalization (Abdullahi & Mansor, 2018; Mubarokah & Rahayu, 2024),
and underscore how robust governance mechanisms can directly counteract these
fraud risk factors. Further, ethics based practices create new openings for
organizations, strengthen good governance whistleblowing mechanisms,
sustainability, performance and growth and governance measures can
pre-emptively tackle.Kulmie and Ibrahim [2]. Their review also identifies the
gap like limited focus on governance challenges in developing countries. The
essence of their research is that corporate governance plays a fundamental role
in mitigating fraud risk in the banking sector and effective governance
frameworks utilize both human and technological resources to strengthen
internal controls and promote ethical leadership which is crucial in mitigating
fraud risks.
B. Fraud Triangle
Theory
Donald Cressey, a criminologist, established the study of fraud in
the 1950s. He was curious to know why people commit fraud, and his research led
to the conclusion that i) people initially take the responsibility of trust
positively, and ii) they are later forced to break that trust. He then
explained how these three elements (pressure, opportunity and rationalization)
must all exist before someone will commit wrongdoing. They described that trust
violators [i.e., potential offenders], “when they have perceived themselves as
facing a non-shareable financial problem and are conscious of the fact that
this problem can be 'solved' secretly by a violation of the institution of
financial trust. They may apply to their own conduct in that situation
verbalizations which help them dovetail conceptions of themselves as trustful
persons with conceptions of themselves as users of the trust funds or
property.” (Cressey 1953) [1]
Pressure is the factor that leads to unethical behaviour. Every
person who thinks to commit fraud faces some pressure to commit unethical
behaviour. Pressure is a factor to commit fraud; it can be further classified
into three types of pressure which are personal, employment stress and external
pressure. Then comes the second element, Opportunity which is created due to
ineffective control or governance system that allows an individual to commit
organisational fraud. It can also be referred to as a necessary point because
fraud can not occur until and unless the opportunity is present even if the
pressure is extreme. Rationalisation the third element is the reasons and
excuses that people give to argue that unethical behavior is not the same as
criminal behavior due to lack of internal ethical compass, or moral reasoning.
So it is the bridge between pressure and opportunity when someone justifies the
fraud [1]. Thus with fraud triangle implications, In banks corporate governance
primarily targets reducing the opportunity by tightening controls and
oversights in the banks, while ethical leadership addresses rationalization and
organizational culture helps in mitigating pressure.
C. Corporate
Governance Theory
Corporate Governance may be described as the manner in which
companies are governed or controlled. In the world of multi branched banking
competition good governance is what everyne is trying to imbibe in their
workplace. Thus corporate governance becomes very important for which corporate
governance theories are used to guide the mechanisms, processes of an
organisation for implementation of a good corporate governance. Key governance
frameworks such as Agency Theory, Stakeholder Theory and Stewardship Theory are
essential for evaluating how oversight mechanisms can determine fraudulent
behavior. Agency Theory: Much of the research related to corporate governance
is based on agency theory, the principals have their own interest and so do the
agents. Principally focuses on agent-principal conflict where agents are
managers, the principals are the owners and the board of directors acts as a
monitoring mechanism [3] (Mallin, 2004). Thus weak governance allows
opportunistic behaviour in the agents. Three assumptions in this theory about
human nature are: it assumes that human beings act in self interest, have
limited reasoning capabilities for future perceptions and are reluctant to take
risks [2] (Mubarokah & Rahayu 2024). Agency theory relates agency problems
with banking fraud, wherein agents misuse information for self interest causing
losses to the principals leading to huge losses incurred by banks, clients, and
owners. This indicates the weak corporate governance which leads to fraudulent
management activities [2]. Stakeholder Theory - This theory focuses on the
issues concerning the stakeholders in an institution. It encourages inclusive
governance to balance interests. It specifies that organisations provide a
balance between the interest of its diverse stakeholders in order to ensure
that each stakeholder interest is taken into concern [3]. Stewardship Theory
-On the other hand, stewardship theory provides an opposite model of management
from agency theory in which managers are seen as stewards acting in the best
interests of owners. Steward behavior, in contrast to that of agency behavior,
is beneficial to the enterprise and hence a higher utility considered than
individualistic self-interest behavior. This behavior has an interest in
accomplishing goals of the organization benefiting both the organization and
other stakeholders. They require less control as they are only working for the
benefit of the principals, but sometimes may be misused in fraud prone
environments when the pressure element is high and leads to opportunity.
D. Corporate
Governance Mechanisms in Banking
An effective corporate governance framework is essential for
establishing a structure that protects the confidentiality and integrity of
bank and helps to reduce fraud. Studies show that strong corporate governance
correlates with lower incidence of fraud in financial institutions.
E. Board of
Directors Composition and Roles
The entire responsibility for bank governance is cast on the Board
of Directors, as they are accountable to the shareholders for creating, thus
delivering, sustainable value through adequate management supervision [4]. The
making of strategic decisions and control are the two quite essential duties of
the Board of Directors. The composition of and functioning of the BODs are
critical in shaping the governance landscape of banks. An independent and
freely functional board without any external interference can provide unbiased
oversight and strategic decision. Defining policies, endorsing tactical
initiatives, and guaranteeing compliance with regulatory standards are board
functions. Good corporate governance leads to transparency within the
management and helps in identifying potential risks [5].
F. Audit
Committees
Audit Committees ensure the credibility of the books and records by
mitigating fraudulent falsification like misrepresentation in the books. They
serve as a critical line of defense against financial misconduct. The
responsibilities of an audit committee includes supervising internal and
external audit, overseeing internal controls and ensuring fairness in financial
reporting. Financial literacy, member independence and their control over the
working and proactive risk assessment shows the effectiveness of the audit
committees [4].
G. Risk
Governance and Compliance Functions
They are the backbone of a bank's internal control framework as is
the formal structure and processes by which risk management responsibilities
are defined, delegated and supervised. Effective risk governance and compliance
functions facilitate continuous monitoring and evaluation of risk assessment
methodologies adopted, as well as an assessment of potential impacts from
scenarios completed with relevant risk mitigation mediated plans. It
identifies, assesses and reduces the fraud risks using systematic oversight and
evaluation with respect to adequacy in the application of bank specific risk
management policies and internal controls and preventatives. Effective risk
governance and compliance functions enable continuous risk assessment, scenario
analysis, and execution of risk mitigation strategies. [5]. The risk governance
framework and compliance functions help in mitigating the opportunity element
by strong control, transparency and ethical practices.
Fig. 1. Corporate Governance Mechanism, Source: [4]
H. Internal
Control Systems
The internal control system ensures that the operations align with
objectives while minimizing the risk of fraudulent activity. It refers to the
systems, policies and procedures implemented by the bank to mitigate fraud,
ensure accuracy of financial records. It helps in mitigating the opportunity
component of fraud triangle theory. It ensures robust internal oversight with
regular internal audits which helps identify lack in control, identifying
process gaps and potential fraud indicators. If there is proper segregation of
duties, proper authorization it ensures stronger internal control
implementation in the banks and enhances transparency, prevention of
unauthorized access and increases the detection of fraud [5]. The COSO internal
control framework is the golden standard for fraud prevention as it helps
organisations align their internal controls with their objectives which
indirectly ensure effective risk management and financial reporting. It
emphasizes controlling the environment, helps in risk assessment, oversight on
information sharing and continuous monitoring. Thus an effective internal
control system aligned with the COSO framework helps banks to prevent financial
manipulation.
I. Research Gap
There are a number of studies present on governance and fraud
separately; some also focus on relation between fraud triangle components,
fraud diamond components and governance mechanisms in the banking sector.
Limited research exists that theoretically and empirically connects
corporate governance to each element of the fraud triangle theory, Individually
both corporate governance and fraud triangle theory are well explained in
various research.
Many studies are very common in the context of non-financial firms
generally which means sector specific studies are not present that particularly
throws light on the role of governance in banks to mitigate fraud risk.
While numerous researches have investigated this by focusing on the
developed economies, there remains a research gap in understanding how
corporate governance mechanisms operate within developing nations such as
India.
III. Research Methodology
This research combines a structured, statistically driven approach
including both qualitative and quantitative approach to examine how corporate
governance impact fraud risk in Indian banks.
Fig.
2.
Research Design
A. Quantitative
Approach
It includes analysis of data in terms of frequency, scale to
understand the role of corporate government mechanisms and have insight about
the frauds in banks.
B. Qualitative
Approach
Having insights on secondary data such as RBI annual reports, case
studies of major frauds like PNB case, Nirav Modi case and other fraud incident
reports to identify governance failures.
This research includes application of thematic analysis, case study
analysis to understand the gap in governance practices and how they can be
tackled with the fraud triangle elements.
IV. Findings
A. Key Findings
The findings reflect the importance of corporate governance as with
help of the questionnaire it is clear that governance systems that have strong
audit committees and internal audit control systems in their mechanism are more
effective because they have a direct role in monitoring and controlling the
activities to ensure that no fraudulent activity is committed. Additionally
there is a need for whistleblower protection policies which makes the
governance system much stronger with all the other mechanisms as it helps in
increasing the chances of having prior knowledge about any fraud taking place
and also leads to improvement in the governance system.
Pressure is the fraud driver which leads to fraudulent activities.
The findings reflect that around 65 % people agree that due to performance
pressure and 45 % agree that due to financial pressure the fraudulent
activities increase. In case of rationalization 50% (10 respondents )
encountered employees justifying minor fraud occasionally or more, and 20 % (4
respondents ) viewed such justification as “right,” revealing ethical
challenges.
The findings also reflect the agreement of 80 % of respondents that
weak internal controls lead to occurrence of opportunity elements for fraud and
throw light on the importance of strong internal control which helps in
reducing the opportunity to commit any fraud.
Based on the opinions of individuals working in banks on corporate
governance, this implies that proper governance systems and mechanisms are
essential in banks, as they mitigate fraud risk through effective control
systems, policies and frameworks that reduce the chances of fraud occurring.
B. Contribution
of the Study
From the findings it can be analyzed how important an effective
governance system is to mitigate the fraudulent elements of the fraud triangle
theory which will help in reducing the risk factor in the banks. The
implications from this study are as follows:
Besides effective control systems, cultural intervention should also
be present, meaning governance frameworks should focus on creating ethical
surroundings. Providing incentives to always work ethically without any
fraudulent motive, and providing information about the consequences that can
arise from fraudulent behaviour through clear policies, will help address and
mitigate the rationalization element.
Focus on strengthening policies of the governance system and strong
enforcement of the policies on a regular basis, Banks should prioritise on the
implementation of the whistleblower policies which will directly address in
reducing the insider opportunities.
Also there should be proper resource allocation for the governance
system that will help in making it more effective to reduce risk through
investing in technologies like automated control systems which will reduce the
burden of keeping oversight manually and chances of biases. Thus it will help
in monitoring all the activities in the banks and mitigate the opportunity
element which arises in case of using digital platforms and high volume
transactions.
Taken together, these contributions show that ethical culture,
stronger policy enforcement, and investment in technology-driven controls
reinforce one another, giving banks a more complete way to reduce fraud risk.
V. Conclusion
The study aims to research the role of corporate governance in fraud
risk mitigation in the banking sector measured against fraud triangle theory.
It includes theoretical understanding from various already existing theories
other than fraud triangle theories like agency theory, stewardship theory and
research articles. The quantitative analysis is done by conducting surveys and
then analysing them and forming interpretation with alignment to the research
objective. The key findings include:
The pressure element of the fraud triangle theory is the main aspect
which leads to motivation in the bank employees to commit fraud. It can be
stated as the key contributor for fraudulent behaviour. The pressure element
can be in the form of performance pressure or personal financial pressure which
can lead to fraudulent behaviour in the employees.
Corporate governance mechanisms will include the study of board of
directors, audit committees, internal audit department, and whistleblowing
mechanisms. All these mechanisms play a vital role for an effective governance
system in banks in terms of reducing fraud risk by eliminating the opportunity
element of the fraud triangle theory because if there will be loopholes in the
governance mechanism it will lead to employees seeking an opportunity to
conduct fraudulent activity.
The research also targeted the importance of the whistleblowing
mechanism because as per the survey conducted according to respondents there is
inconsistency in the presence and awareness of whistleblowing mechanisms. The
negligence that whistleblowing mechanisms face in the governance system affects
the prior detection of large frauds because employees do not feel confident in
reporting unethical practices. Simultaneously it also leads to inefficiency of
the governance system in mitigating the rationalization element of the fraud
triangle theory which occurs due to weak corporate governance mechanisms.
The findings also highlight the challenges faced by governance
systems like weak enforcement of policies, resource constraint and delay in
latest technological adoption, lack of ethical training leads to weak corporate
governance systems as the fraud triangle elements ( pressure, opportunity and
rationalization ) raises risk of fraudulent activity.
The research helps in application of the three elements by linking
it to the corporate governance system which helps in reducing the fraud risk
and with proper understanding of fraud triangle elements the banks can make
necessary changes in the governance system and policies to reduce the risk of
fraud.
A. Scope for
Further Research
1) Comparative Analysis: This research targets the banking sector in general. Future research
comparison of private sector, public sector and foreign banks in India can lead
to more sector specific comparison and help in understanding their practices.
2) Inclusion of Behavioral
and Cultural factor: Future research can explore
how other fraud triangle theory elements, culture and employees behaviour lead
to fraud risk and how corporate governance mechanisms help in mitigating these
factors.
3) Inclusion of Qualitative
Interviews: This research is conducted only on the
basis of surveys in future research interviews with senior bank managers;
compliance and audit officers can be integrated to have more knowledge about
the governance system in banks and more knowledgeable insights.
4) Understanding post fraud
effect and recovery by the governance system: In
future research it can be explored how banks rebuild the governance system
after a collapse caused by fraud and what measures they take to come back with
a more efficient corporate governance system after a major setback.
Lastly, this research shows how corporate governance is not just for
the sake of regulatory obligation but works as an efficient mechanism to combat
fraudulent activities and how it evolves with time and changing fraud patterns
and evolution in the banking sector. It addresses the pressure, opportunity and
rationalization elements of the fraud triangle stating how a corporate
governance helps in mitigating these elements and reducing fraud risk. It shows
how a strong governance culture incorporated with transparency, accountability
and ethical leadership leads to sustainability of banks with less fraudulent
activity and also ensuring public trust is maintained.
🖼️
Figures & Tables
📚
References
Meet the Mavericks: From humble beginnings to billion-dollar dreams – here’s Byju Raveendran’s fascinating success story
Byju’s on Deloitte’s Fast 50 India List
Byju’s is now a part of Harvard Business case study
Byju’s app self- learns patterns as students spent more time on it.
Byju's Acquires TutorVista, Edurite from Pearson
Byju’s Acquires Osmo for $120 Million
Byju’s Acquires WhiteHat Jr for $300 Million
Byju's Acquires Aakash for $950 Million
Byju’s Acquires Great Learning for $600 Million
Learning app BYJU’S Replaces Oppo on Indian Cricket Team Jersey
Setback for Byju’s: Delaware Supreme Court upholds ruling that found Byju’s in default on $1.2 bn Term loan B
Byju’s Under Government Scrutiny After Deloitte Resigns
SFIO commences probe into Ed-tech major Byju’s irregularities
Byju’s under scrutiny again government launches new investigation into finances
Byju’s auditor BDO resigns after start of bankruptcy proceedings firm says
BCCI initiates insolvency plea against Byju's over unpaid dues
Four biggest Foreign investors in Byju’s make a request to Supreme Court
Byju’s from 22 billion valuation to zero
Byju’s debt crisis troubles US Ed-tech subsidiaries it no longer owns
Supreme Court sets aside Byju’s settlement with BCCI Orders Company to deposit Rs. 158 crore creditors’ Escrow
SC orders Escrowed 158 crore in Byju’s matters to be deposited with CoC observes CIRP violations in NCLAT order
Byju’s CEO Raveendran’s removal is not justified in absence of forensic audit: Amarjit Chopra
Lessons Byju’s board never learnt
Its wartime but it’s not a challenge: Byju Raveendran on the future of online learning
Classic case of a mismanaged company what led to the downfall of Byju’s
⚖️
Ethics Declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Users can freely download, share, and reuse the article for any purpose (even commercially), as long as they give proper credit to the original author.
Competing Interests
Users can freely download and share the article, but they are strictly prohibited from using it or selling it for commercial profit.
Consent for Publication
Users can only read and view the article for personal use; they cannot copy, redistribute, or reuse any part of it without explicit permission from your journal.
📋
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailComplete editorial process — cryptographically verified
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailEditorial Process Audit Trail
NFSU-2026-V2-I1-J-2026-0030-CHAIN
✓ Verified · 8 blocks · Genesis 0x9f2bManuscript Received
20 Nov 2026 16:50
Editor Assigned
20 Nov 2026 16:50
Passed Initial Screening
20 Nov 2026 16:51
Similarity Check Completed
20 Nov 2026 16:51
Editor decision: Accepted
20 Nov 2026 17:03
Ready for Production
20 Nov 2026 17:21
Sent to Issue Manager
20 Nov 2026 17:24
Published Online
20 Nov 2026 17:31
🔐
Verification & Trust
CompliantCOPE · ICMJE · FAIR · ORCID · CLOCKSS
Verification & Trust
CompliantArticle Integrity Verified
All editorial chain blocks cryptographically verified · Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, and FAIR standards